Elegy to the Feminist Peace Collective

On political exile and the authoritarian temptation of radical care

This elegy is the result of months of political labor, finally breaking the silence. Elegies are written for the dead, they are sad and mournful. This essay is not much different from the classic elegy, but writing at the point where grief and anger merge has more of a political archival character than “crying for the dead.” This elegy is for the Feminist Peace Collective.

The Collective was formed in 2020 during and after the Second Karabakh War, when war was celebrated as national freedom and honor, and refusing it could make you a traitor. Three people, including myself, participated in its creation. In turn, several other friends and comrades supported us. By that time, I had already been involved in feminist, queer, and anti-militarist organizing in Azerbaijan for years, as well as peacebuilding processes between Armenians and Azerbaijanis. At a time when the outbreak of the 44-day war showed us that all this peacebuilding talk was nothing beyond UN jargon, I went to the war zone to help displaced women and families against a backdrop of helplessness and desperation. By distributing aid in this desperate time, when we had neither the power nor the means to stop or oppose the war , we were chasing a mirage. I remember suddenly thinking, amidst the sound of distant shells on one side and the distribution of flour sacks and second-hand clothing from Baku on the other: enough is enough to clean up the ruins of this authoritarian, capitalist war. When we intervened and healed, we were not only healing ourselves, but also the system that had wounded us. It was time for a different politics.

This was my political impulse behind our collective. It had “feminist peace” in its name, but it did not simply aim to make liberal peacebuilding more inclusive or to add women to the existing national peacemaking system or the UN lexicon. It opposed that very thing and instead created a radical anti-war politics. Our feminism could not be separated from anti-militarism or anti-capitalism. And this meant that everyday politics had to be directly linked to the larger structures of the authoritarian state and global capital and its war machine. Since then, we have been writing, translating, protesting, networking, and making statements together with our comrades from Armenia and sometimes Georgia, thinking not only within and about Azerbaijan, but also beyond its borders. We did this with almost no infrastructure and through unpaid labor. At the beginning there were three of us, then two, then three again, then four. By then, we were scattered across the cold and pale countries of Europe, doing things to both provide for ourselves and fulfill our political obligations. That is, there was no institutional machine to keep the collective alive. We kept it alive.

But the state did let our politics to remain in words. As Azerbaijan’s attacks intensified in 2023 and finally took full control of Nagorno-Karabakh, our anti-war statements attracted more and more hostile attention. After our activities, including the protests around COP29 in Tbilisi in November 2024, the Azerbaijani puppet media showed my pictures on big screens and branded me a national traitor. Not content with their smear campaign, they presented me as the wife of Bahruz Samadov, a researcher they had arrested for their anti-war activities, and at every turn, they continued to put the stigma of treason around our necks. I was directly and repeatedly targeted in public in connection with the work we did through the Feminist Peace Collective. I do not, of course, want to present this persecution as some kind of heroic medal. Suffering exile does not automatically make anyone a better revolutionary, nor certainly a more pleasant comrade. But even if former comrades can change the passwords of the platform you founded overnight, political persecution does not end overnight. Therefore, the fact that the Collective changed its name a few days ago and redirected its activities in a different direction already compels me to share my position.

Tired comrades and the anger in void

Fanon wrote decades ago about how colonized individuals resort to violence and anger to reinvent themselves, to liberate themselves, and to become human again, and how this is essential. This summer, as I reread Fanon, a paragraph in Sartre’s preface to it seemed to answer a question I had been pondering for months:

“If this suppressed fury fails to find an outlet, it turns in a vacuum and devastates the oppressed creatures themselves. In order to free themselves they even massacre each other. The different tribes fight between themselves since they cannot face the real enemy — and you can count on colonial policy to keep up their rivalries; the man who raises his knife against his brother thinks that he has destroyed once and for all the detested image of their common degradation, even though these expiatory victims don’t quench their thirst for blood”. (Sartre 1961)

In the small civil society and social movement arena of Azerbaijan, we often come across these conflicts, the need to put a knife to our comrade’s throat. One of the reasons for this is precisely because we live in such a colonized situation. The Azerbaijani government behaves no differently from colonial regimes. The tactics and psychological weapons it uses have been aimed at actively destroying social movements for years, using fear, suspicion, and control techniques rather than direct violence. And our struggle against such a violent system is similar to decolonization movements. However, against this background, political defeats leave behind a very painful anger. That anger cannot grow and find a place for itself. Until it is directed at the one who raised it or at the one closest to it.

My goal in giving this incomplete analysis is to share what happened, honestly, from my side. That means, what I share here should not make the Azerbaijani government too happy, because what is happening actually means the arrival of clarity. Those who crush reality are busy trampling on our hopes. But no matter how much the control and fear system they have established tries to crush reality, the truth always wins and will come. Of course, some fall into these traps and do not learn the lesson. But just as some of us helped each other to continue life by keeping each other “awake” and without experiencing neurosis during the war, there are those who are with us in this difficult period so that we do not lose our vigilance and alertness, and this article is also for them.

As for the Feminist Peace Collective, by 2025-2026 we were barely able to write or create. Our meetings had become a rehash of old frustrations, a discussion of other people’s politics and ideologies, and a review of our proposals that could not be translated into collective action. Looking back now, I don’t think it was a crisis of our motivation or our capacity. But I think something more material and more destructive was happening. We were tired. I was tired. We were left with the imprisonment of our comrades in Azerbaijan, political exile, asylum, visas, finding jobs, insecurity in our own families and in some of our own. The accumulation of political defeats had slowly exhausted our ability not only to imagine something new, but also to organize in general.

And most importantly, the anger was well-loaded inside us, and for me it still is. We needed to be able to say all of this out loud at this point, without immediately blaming one person for everything. We needed to be able to say out loud how years of repression had affected our ability to imagine, organize, trust, and simply live together. We needed to be able to confront, for once, our obsession with capitalist productivity, which we criticized ourselves for, and its rather ironic repetition within our collective. We needed to stop treating fatigue as a flaw and embrace it as a political condition. Maybe we didn’t need to write another manifesto, change our name, or come up with another grand plan to save the movement. Maybe we needed time to grieve what had happened to us, to regain our political imagination, and to reflect on why we had come together in the first place. We could just breathe, maybe breathe together. It seems that even that required political disagreement.

Instead, fatigue seemed to grow as if it were a peak to be conquered as soon as possible. I was repeatedly warned that I was “slowing down” the collective, as if the only thing standing between the three exhausted exiled comrades and the flowering of revolutionary politics was my unfortunate existence. The logic seemed to be that if I stopped asking questions, stepped aside, or simply disappeared, the remaining three could finally unleash their organizational potential: unite the Azerbaijani exile community, create an NGO, and perhaps continue their revolution (with an NGO?).

Now, if you’re wondering if we’ve found a way out of this political quagmire, I’m sorry to say that we haven’t passed the test. Quite the opposite. Almost everything I suggested, questioned, or disagreed with along the way turned into a problem, until I ended up becoming the problem itself. I rose to a pretty high position for someone who was exhausted.

Seven accusations and my responses

I have hesitated to tell this story for months, because to tell it would be to expose moments that I once believed were worthy of protection in our intimacy. But I think I have long mistaken my silence for solidarity. I thought that protecting my former comrades from public targeting was part of protecting the political world we had built together. Because I still think that way in part, this article does not name anyone and does not demand anything from anyone. But I no longer want to be silent. Silence is not always an active act of caring. Silence is sometimes a never-ending labor we do for the very people who have hurt us. And I am giving up that labor.

Rather than burying the accusations against me under the language of some “interpersonal conflict,” I want to name them. This writing style is familiar to those who follow the Collective. When the Azerbaijani government targeted us in the same way, we noted and responded to each accusation in our response to it. Today, I will try to archive the same by sharing the accusations against me and the harm they have done to me, and to be the voice of comrades who have experienced similar harm and faced betrayal in social movements. In other words, this history that you will read is highly subjective and in no way aims to declare myself innocent or clear my name.

1. “You seized the protest, exposed yourself, and created a hierarchy.”

During the COP29 protests in Tbilisi, when we protested with other activists and Greta Thunberg to oppose the Azerbaijani regime’s remarkable environmental performance, we found ourselves in a rather strange debate: should the faces of those who oppose it be revealed during a protest against an authoritarian state? The differences of opinion were real, and so were the dangers. Some comrades insisted that everyone remain anonymous, their faces covered. I argued that anonymity and visibility were not revolutionary doctrines pitted against each other, but tactical choices that different people could make according to their circumstances. Especially if we were standing next to one of the world’s most well-known climate activists. The international and Georgian press needed no other reason to turn their cameras on Greta Thunberg. What worried me was that Azerbaijanis protesting their government’s repression could disappear into the background of their own protest. I wanted it to be clear that we were not just creating an exotic political landscape for the intervention of an international celebrity. We were there with our own demands, our own histories of repression, and our own political voices. I wasn’t asking anyone to show their faces, to be visible. I just wanted those who wanted to be visible to not be forbidden from doing so.

In the end, the majority agreed to not show their faces. At one point in the protest, I and another activist briefly revealed our faces to speak to Azerbaijani opposition journalists. This visibility, of course, made us—especially the two of us—active targets, as we had expected. But regardless of all this, the main problem was not the punishments and conditions the government imposed on us, but my revealing my face in that short time. It seemed that I had committed a rather extraordinary political crime. I was later told that I had captured the attention and the protest, undermined our collective tactics, and gained strength by showing my face. I had not known that the revolution depended so much on the visibility of our faces.

Of course, there was a serious question hidden behind these absurd claims. Anonymity is useful, especially when political movements are small and authoritarian states are trying to expose activists. I did not and still do not reject this risk. But neither anonymity nor visibility is inherently radical. Just as an open face does not establish a dictatorship, a covered face does not automatically create a horizontal policy. And most importantly, during the protest, everyone joins in, accepting their responsibilities. We had gathered this as a good experience from the protests in Azerbaijan. My former comrades, without any experience of protesting in Azerbaijan, naturally tried to be cautious in their protests against the Azerbaijani government in another country.

The protest itself was chaotic, and it is not uncommon for a few activists with no experience in street protests to try to organize an international political intervention within a few days. Some comrades left before the protest was over, without informing the rest. That very night, when we reunited after the protest, one of the old comrades who had abandoned us in the middle of the protest accused me of aggressively taking over the protest. I remember that this was a very strange accusation from someone who had abandoned the protest in the middle of the protest. Months later, we talked, hugged, and I foolishly believed that we had reached an understanding. Apparently, all these events were simply filed away in a secret archive, ready to be pulled out of the archive and thrown at me when new evidence of my flawed character was required.

The strangest thing was that the comrade who did not want to show their face during the protest volunteered to participate in a podcast conversation with Greta Thunberg, which was later published online. It seems that this visibility had a rather flexible political character. In one context, it was a legitimate act of public communication; in another, it was a dangerous empowerment of personal power. I am quite willing to accept that different contexts pose different risks. That was my argument in the first place. But instead of discussing these differences, we somehow arrived at a moral distinction between the virtuous anonymous revolutionary and the openly power-hungry dissident. What should have remained a disagreement about tactics turned into a character and ideological problem. So, while the Azerbaijani government was busy criminalizing the opposition, we were debating whether the opposition had the political right to appear as an opposition.

2. ” Because you revealed your face, others suffered.”

After the protest, the Azerbaijani government continued what it had long known. When it could not punish the dissident sufficiently, it punished the family. The mother of the friend who accused me of being visible was fired from her job where she had worked for decades. Officially, it was a staff reduction. However, the family was told that her dismissal was related to her child`s political activities. The reason I can and should write about this here is because the person herself has already publicly stated this.

Family punishment is, of course, very painful and burdensome. I understood the pain of this punishment, perhaps more than I felt it. Years ago, my participation in the protests in Baku almost ended my relationship with my family. I had learned, that is, long before exile, that authoritarian repression does not need to arrest you to destroy your entire life. Sometimes it simply enters your home, sits among you and the people you love, and has hard conversations about the unbearable cost of your political beliefs. I had already paid this price. Therefore, I was neither surprised by the state’s tactics, nor inclined to interpret this punishment as something unprecedented. This does not mean, however, that I disregarded the suffering of either my comrade or their mother. It meant that I knew by what mechanism it was created.

What increasingly worried me was the shifting of responsibility for that mechanism from the state to me. My decision to expose my face during the protest resurfaced in subsequent disagreements within our group, as if the Azerbaijani government’s repressions were an unfortunate consequence of my failure to follow the correct revolutionary dress code. The regime had targeted us for our political activities, but somehow I had to respond to its methods. This notorious division tactic was exactly in line with the state’s plan: the state would portray one activist as good and another as bad, keep one under constant surveillance and organize troll attacks, and sometimes protect the other as if they were in a mediocre position, sometimes punish them with their family. Again, the state punishes. And the activists are forced to persecute each other. That is, there is no need for additional police and security officers. PSYOP, or psychological warfare, had successfully carried out its operation.

I do not deny that there are risks for those who choose visibility, including anonymity. These risks deserve active discussion and collective responsibility. But there is a profound difference between examining our political decisions and placing responsibility for authoritarian violence on the person resisting. The moment we begin to treat each other as authors of state repression, we allow that repression to spill over into the intimate relationships of resistance itself. And this is perhaps one of authoritarianism’s most successful achievements. Destroying solidarity from within.

3. “You were uncaring and tried to harm other relationships.”

In late 2025, during a conversation in a bar in Berlin, the question arose of whether it was possible to love someone with whom you were not ideologically on the same page. When I said that it was not possible for me, the other comrade denied it and said that it was possible, citing as an example another member of our collective, with whom they were friends but ideologically different. What bothered me most was hearing another member of our collective speak in terms of their ideology and personal weaknesses in front of people outside our group. I withdrew from this conversation. Later, this withdrawal was interpreted as coldness, or more precisely, “indifference” and “uncaring”, and even, when I later exposed this episode, it was labelled as an attempt to disrupt other relationships.

When I recounted what I remembered from that conversation, my testimony was rejected, I was accused of lying, and I was accused of making up stories to turn my comrades against each other. I suggested asking other people who were there; they refused. Later, I learned from witnesses that they had been addressed privately and had confirmed the essence of what I had said. All this reproach and insult kept me thinking for days: those who accused me of “carelessness,” “indifference,” “lying,” and “trying to hold on to power” were doing it themselves. Most of us know well how the person who named the problem can become the problem. But this was the first time I had felt it. The comrades who accused me of carelessness were themselves crossing all boundaries and oscillating between cruelty and the childish desire to have the last word. Care should actually be the rejection of this cruelty and the fetish of having the last word. But instead we had become captive to a second fetish—a “care fetishism” (Farris 2025). Care had been transformed into such an impeccable ideal that, while my failure to show zealous concern during this strange episode was interpreted as a lack of care and my subsequent discussion of it as cruelty, the central figure of the event, along with their own statements and accusations, had vanished from the picture.

4. “You are patronizing, manipulative, narcissistic, and abusive.”

I would like to point out here that the main escalation started in January of this year when the newest member of the collective, the 4th member, did not like both the name of the collective and the its focus of peace, but rather suggested that it should turn into a leftist exile movement and, if possible, an NGO, and after I objected to this, they said in a group`s chat message that they would leave the group. And after the widening disagreement, they, along with the other two people, began to accuse me of patronizing and educating others, monopolizing the political space, controlling the collective, manipulating relationships, and being uncaring. They tried to “show my place” with long messages and accusations, insulting me with words like “violent,” “narcissistic,” and “liberal.”

I do not deny that being a founder of the Collective, building its platforms and its ideological foundation, writing most of its texts, having a longer experience of protest, or taking a visible position can give informal power. Perhaps I spoke too harshly, took too much responsibility, or did not feel it when others felt unable to intervene. Such things can and should be criticized specifically. But what exactly did I control? I supported the joining of new members. I did not claim exclusive ownership of the feminist peace project. Unlike other members, I did not have a direct connection to any donor or similar organization that I could financially control or claim recognition for. Moreover, this was not my first experience. I had also previously walked away from groups and collectives that I had helped to create and put a lot of effort into and moved on to other political movements and groups.

It never occurred to me that I would encounter so much harm in a collective of 3–4 people that claimed to be horizontal. Informal power does not disappear simply by discursively saying “I am an anarchist”, “I am a radical”. That power passes into friendships, unspoken alliances, control over procedures, control over archives, access to material resources, and the ability to decide which person’s feelings constitute the truth of the collective. A majority of three against one person does not automatically have the character of truth just because it is a majority. The main issue is who has the say when there are differences of opinion between these 4 people, whose grief is the grief, who opens the archives and brings facts from the past, who polices every word you say.

5. “ You abused your authority by allowing the wrong person to access our platform ”​​​

Another accusation was related to a solidarity text for a Talysh activist published on our website. They accused me of opening our platform to someone whose politics they considered nationalist. In fact, the comrade who initiated this accusation was also a person who was not interested in any political work with Armenians. This person claimed that I had used my authority to include that publication, which should not have been there, precisely because they were supposedly my friend. This claim was absurd in every sense. Because first of all, this article was a support article for a Talysh activist who was unjustly imprisoned, and we were speaking from that position of solidarity. Second, the person who wrote it was neither my close friend nor a nationalist. Third, other members had given the green light to share the article. So, if the problem was that we did not have an editorial procedure, we could have created one. That was simply not the case. The point was to create every little problem and blame it on me and, against this background, blame me for being authoritarian. In reality, their politics of division was aiming to label not only me but also other people in the community to prove their ideological purism.

6. “Going to therapy is an individualistic thing.”

Yes, my former comrades who accused me of neglect and patronizing also claimed that me, just and only me, going to therapy was an individualistic behavior. My ex-comrade, who gave me a lecture through a long monologue what a liberal tool therapy is, did not hesitate to give me this wise advice, despite the fact that they were not with me at any difficult moment in my life, did not share any intimacy with me, and did not share any of my pain.

Many years ago Edward Said was writing about exile: “Exile is strangely compelling to think about but terrible to experience. It is the unhealable rift forced between a human being and a native place, between the self and its true home: its essential sadness can never be surmounted”. It can change a person, deepen their fears, and expose them to the uncertainties of life. We all experienced it. Just with different social capitals. Some have family support, some have friends who stay in the same city, even in the same neighborhood. Some wait for years in political asylums in remote villages that they don’t know at all to get their documents. Often, due to this lost social capital, we can go through processes we never thought about, accept supports we cannot choose. Therapy was this support for me.

We know from history that some therapy methods was aimed at keeping people under control rather than a healing tool. But this does not mean that everyone should give up personal support in order to prove their commitment to collective freedom. And why should the mere fact that I have the means to access therapy be considered at odds with radical politics? Isn’t radical care, in essence, the very ability to heal?!

Our bodies need rest. People need food, security, love, and sometimes professional care. No movement can live forever in good conscience by stigmatizing the people who make its politics possible. So the question was not whether therapy would replace some radical future. The question was whether there would be someone you could fight for tomorrow, someone you could lean on, someone you could fight for arm in arm.

7. “You prevent us from moving forward and renewing ourselves”

But the main disagreement was about the future of the collective. The three wanted to establish an organization focused on the Azerbaijani exile, potentially an NGO, and change our name. Let me state my position without speculation. I was portrayed as having declared the name Feminist Peace Collective a sacred name and appointed myself its permanent guardian. I was neither against the name change nor was I particularly committed to preserving it. The problem was never the name. If we could no longer find the energy, credibility, or political imagination to create together, what would a new name solve? What, apart from the unresolved contradictions of the old, did we plan to bring to this grand new beginning? We could change the name, register an NGO (really?), and declare the rebirth of radical politics. But exhaustion with a new name is still exhaustion. And I was not sure that our collective crisis could be resolved by such changes.

My objection to becoming an NGO was direct. Because I had seen enough of the professional civil society circus, and they couldn’t convince me of the fantasy that the NGO we would create this time would be different. It would be radical, horizontal, anti-capitalist, maybe even revolutionary. We would rob the rich and, of course, remain completely independent of the institutions that financed us. The revolution would be financed, but it would never compromise. What a beautiful mirage it’d be, as Lenin would say: Allah alone knows!

But what were we really proposing? Another institution to manage the suffering of people in exile? A self-appointed group of representatives who would turn political struggle into donor attention, who would translate solidarity into projects? And who would receive this solidarity? People who were radical enough, who were content enough, who we considered worthy of our care? Were we about to become revolutionary social welfare workers for the Azerbaijani exile community, assessing political compliance, distributing recognition, perhaps handing out money, and determining who was eligible for collective belonging? Although we could hardly accept the disagreement between the four of us, we somehow imagined that we were ready to organize solidarity for an entire community. Apparently, we could not yet take care of each other without a tribunal, but perhaps with enough institutional support we could finally professionalize the process. Frankly, it was a very impressive plan.

Court under the guise of care

Before our last meeting, we had a meeting to resolve the conflict. By the way, all these meetings were conducted online. I was working abroad for my research. The date and time of the meeting were set by the other three members. I was told that if I did not attend, decisions could be made without me. Despite the 3-hour time difference between us and a prior commitment I had, these 3 insisted on my presence at the agreed-upon time and day. I attended. Over the course of about five hours, old and new grievances were collected, from COP29 tactics and article decisions to therapy. I felt like the central defendant, not an equal participant in a shared effort to understand what was broken. As if I had been put on the tribunal and now had to answer for everything I did, for every word I said.

I will not claim that every grievance expressed there was fabricated, every hurt was imaginary, or that I could not harm others. If I did, I would be repeating the same moral absolutism that I was trying to criticize. In the eyes of my ex-comrades, I had become the problem, and in this fermented space, there was nothing left but cruelty and political performativity. This whole escalation, which began with the accusation of “carelessness,” actually showed how caring is weaponized, how the fine lines between mutual criticism and individual autonomy are quickly crossed, and how “true” caring is equated with cruelty, with control, with policing.

We apologized to each other during that meeting, but these apologies were almost administrative in nature. Trust had disappeared. After my 5-hour trial, these esteemed 3 judges immediately announced the need for another meeting and a decision on the future of the collective. As soon as this next meeting began, I was asked to state openly whether I wanted to continue working together or not. I asked to meet in person before deciding on our future. I was told that a personal meeting was not possible. At that time, I knew that the other 3 comrades were planning to meet in person without my presence. Perhaps they had their reasons for this meeting. But for me, after all, the contradiction was unbearable. We were too tired to sit together as four, but apparently we were not too tired to sit together as three. In that very meeting, I announced that I could no longer continue with those unbearable contradictions.

On March 1, 2026, I left the Collective. And then for days and months I thought, I grieved, I was angry. Because the end of the collective was not just a political breakup. It meant the loss of a hope, a political language, and experiences that you shared with people you once trusted to resist injustice and ultimately live together. It is a strange sadness to discover that the very people who helped you survive and resist can also become the very people from whom you need distance in order to survive and resist.

Archive and continuity politics

Shortly after I left the collective, within literally 2 hours, I lost access to the collective’s social media accounts, email, and website. I had spent years of unpaid labor building that infrastructure, including writing a significant portion of its content. The years of political labor remained there, but I could no longer access with the platforms I had created. The question arises: when the relationships that supported the collective fall apart, who owns its history? Who stays? Who keeps the passwords? Who changes the name?

A few days ago, the remaining members apparently created a new initiative, the Riche Collective, which means “roots.” But they have presented it as a continuation of the Feminist Peace Collective, and have changed the name of the Feminist Peace Collective everywhere. In short, they claim that their transformation into an Azerbaijani leftist exile community is a continuation of the previous project. Of course, they have every right to create another collective, choose a different name, and engage in political work that I do not want to continue. I do not want to prevent them from organizing. But political continuity cannot be declared by technical control over an Instagram account or a website. It carries a history of labor, shared decisions, repression, risks, and fragmentation. Precisely for this reason, this newly formed collective cannot, under any circumstances, be a continuation of the Feminist Peace Collective.

Edward Said (1984) understood this temptation better than anyone:

“Because exile, unlike nationalism, is fundamentally a discontinuous state of being. Exiles are cut off from their roots, their land, their past. They generally do not have armies or states, although they are often in search of them. Exiles feel, therefore, an urgent need to reconstitute their broken lives, usually by choosing to see themselves as part of a triumphant ideology or a restored people. The crucial thing is that a state of exile free from this triumphant ideology – designed to reassemble an exile’s broken history into a new whole – is virtually unbearable, and virtually impossible in today’s world. Look at the fate of the Jews, the Palestinians and the Armenians”.

Which is why there is something quite ironic in the new name they have chosen. Roots are not only the things from which new life grows. They also carry the memory of what has been cut off. To build a new politics of solidarity among the displaced without ending the past is to sow the future with poisoned seeds. You can change the name of a platform overnight. You cannot change what happens between people.

There is another particularly important point. The fact that the Azerbaijani government publicly targeted me was directly related to the work of the Feminist Peace Collective. My name and face have been exposed, and I continue to live with the consequences of that exposure. Other members have, for understandable reasons, chosen to remain anonymous in some parts of our work. I have respected the differing calculations of risk within the collective. However, anonymity does not mean that the public exposure of one person becomes an inexhaustible source of future organizational legitimacy for others, nor does it mean that the same person is treated as a punching bag within the group and subsequently ostracized.

For this reason, I state clearly:

I have no organizational connection, role, or responsibility with the new collective formed by Richet or the remaining members. I do not speak for it, and it does not speak for me. Its current or future political positions, decisions, and actions are not mine.

The authoritarianism we carry to exile

I have been thinking for months about how we can hurt each other in this way. Exile breaks trust and belonging. In this situation, ordinary relationships can be made to extraordinary demands. For example, some unexpected people can become instant friends, some relationships are formed out of urgency or compulsion. Some people replace friends and family. And when these relationships are broken, the damage begins not just with the disruption of interpersonal relationships, but with the disruption of living itself.

On the one hand, some authoritarian persecution does not automatically make us sympathetic. Nor does feminism, anarchism, Marxism, or anti-authoritarianism give us immunity from domination. We do not simply oppose authoritarian government because we are against it. We have learned habits of suspicion, paranoia, moral certainty, competition for recognition, and fear that the autonomy of others threatens our own. Even when we imagine ourselves politically innocent, we can repeat these habits with the greatest intensity.

The moral tribunal is also attractive precisely because it is a very simple and compassionate method in the face of political failure. Like Sartre’s knife to the throat of his brother. Instead of admitting that four tired comrades in exile have lost the ability to maintain a political collective, it promises precisely that cleansing by pointing to one person as the cause. Remove them and everything can begin again. We will be reborn. But sometimes people have to leave political organizations to protect themselves. Then caring politics requires the ability to say that we are angry, exhausted, hurt each other, and can no longer organize together. I would have liked such honesty from us. But we did not. Instead, we became guardians of each other’s ideological purity, making diagnoses where political arguments should be, interpreting grief as manipulation and hesitation as provocation. We made our differences more and more dangerous by speaking of solidarity. The problem was not a lack of radical vocabulary. We knew the language very well. The problem was that the dictionary didn’t help change our relationship.

I have been silent for months because these histories are intimate and politically sensitive, and I did not want to turn the collapse of a small movement into a spectacle of mutual condemnation. Nor do I want to repeat the cruelty of treating people at their worst as if I knew everything. And not everything can be reduced to this ending. I remember the many moments of solidarity we lived and built together. I remember the writings we shared over the years, the shared risks and feelings. All of this was real. But looking back, I also remember the trial that was set up against me. I remember being told that I was slowing things down. I also remember losing access to the collective’s accounts and now the newly formed group is being presented as an extension of the Feminist Peace Collective.

And I will not allow the political consequences of the work of the Feminist Peace Collective to be silently carried forward, as if I had given my consent to its so-called successors. History belongs neither to those who remain nor to those who leave. It belongs to the labor that created and continues it, to the people who took risks, and to the broader solidarity. And this history deserves honesty, not care fetishism. We cannot overcome the politics of punishment by imposing punishment in the language of care. We cannot grow new roots without confronting what is broken beneath the ground.

My politics did not begin with the Feminist Peace Collective and it does not end there. On the contrary, I have learned a lot in these 6 years, and with the grief I have held, the anger I have held, and the hope around me, I now know that another kind of comradeship is possible. A comradeship that knows how to fight, how to love, how to disagree, and sometimes how to shut up and let each other breathe. Because there is a cruel system that we must overthrow, and it would be very shameful to wear ourselves out in order to overthrow each other first.

References

Farris, Sara R. 2025. ‘Towards a Critique of Care Fetishism: Social Reproduction Feminism and the Ethics of Care’. Feminist Theory, 14647001251376299.

Said, Edward. 1984. ‘Reflections on Exile’. Transatlantic Literary Studies: A Reader, 285–90.

Sartre, Jean-Paul. 1961. Preface to Frantz Fanon’s Wretched of the Earth. Na.